Sangdon Park

Evaluation Criteria

Shared rubric for planner, generator, and evaluator.

Weighted Categories

Design Quality — 40%

Pass examples:

• Cohesive palette
• Intentional typography
• Strong visual hierarchy

Fail examples:

• Generic gradient hero
• Repetitive white-card layout
• No visual identity

Originality — 30%

Pass examples:

• Hard to mistake for generic AI output
• Memorable composition or interaction

Fail examples:

• Bootstrap-like default structure
• Obvious template feel

Technical Completion — 15%

Pass examples:

• Responsive layout works
• No obvious console errors
• Core interactions function

Fail examples:

• Mobile layout breaks
• Broken links
• Script errors

Functionality — 15%

Pass examples:

• Navigation is understandable
• CTA is easy to find
• Content supports the goal

Fail examples:

• User cannot tell what to do next
• Important flow is missing

Final Thresholds

• PASS: total >= 7.0
• CONDITIONAL PASS: total 5.0 to 6.9
• FAIL: total < 5.0
• FAIL automatically if Design Quality or Originality is <= 4